Separating Signal From Noise In Parachute Audits

6th Grade · Science · Activity · shared by Luke Morgan

A 6th Grade Science Fact vs. Opinion Sort activity on parachute audits, teaching students to separate facts from opinions in engineering data.

Preview

📋 Fact vs. Opinion Sort

Name: _________________________ Date: _____________

Topic: Engineering Audit: Parachute Canopy Surface Area and Air Resistance

Before an engineer can certify a new design, they must perform a data audit . This involves "cleaning" the test logs to separate the Signal (facts) from the Noise (opinions). In science, we must rely on objective data to make safety decisions.

A FACT is a statement that can be proven true or false using evidence, data, or observation.

An OPINION is a statement that expresses a personal belief, feeling, or judgment that cannot be proven.

Engineers at the Sky-High Toy Company are auditing the Flight Test Lab Log for the new "Mega-Chute" prototype. The main engineering claim is that increasing the canopy surface area creates more air resistance, which results in a slower descent and longer descent time. To verify this, auditors examine the raw lab entries for specific measurements. The log shows that a small 10-inch canopy had an average descent time of 4.2 seconds. When the surface area was increased to a 20-inch canopy, the descent time increased to 8.5 seconds. The testing environment remained controlled because the laboratory air conditioning was turned off to prevent wind interference. All tests were conducted from a height of 15 feet. While some testers noted that the blue fabric looked much more professional than the red fabric, these individual preferences do not change the physical measurements. Objective data must show a consistent relationship between the size of the parachute and the time it takes to reach the ground.

Directions: You are the Technical Auditor. Read each statement from the Lab Log below. Write F for Fact or O for Opinion on the blank line.

Related teaching materials

Browse more