Doing It Again for Certainty

6th Grade · Science · Reading Passage · shared by Luke Morgan

Get a free 6th Grade Science reading passage on experimental reliability, outliers, and data analysis, using a bridge model example.

Preview

Doing It Again for Reliability

Maya, a sixth-grade engineering student, proudly presented her bridge model. She had spent weeks designing and building it from popsicle sticks and glue, carefully assembling each piece. For its first test, she carefully added small metal washers, one by one, to the center of the bridge until it finally broke. To her surprise and delight, her model held an impressive amount of weight before collapsing with a small crack. Maya cheered, believing her bridge possessed incredible structural integrity , meaning it was very strong and well-built. She felt confident she had created a winning design for the class competition.

However, Maya's teacher encouraged her to perform more tests. The teacher explained that one successful trial, even a very good one, might be an outlier . An outlier is a result that is much higher or lower than most other results in a set of data. An unusually high result might happen due to a lucky glue joint or a slight difference in how weight was applied, while an unusually low result could come from a tiny unnoticed flaw. To fully understand her bridge's typical strength, Maya needed to gather more data. Repeating the experiment multiple times would allow her to verify that her results were consistent and trustworthy.

Recognizing the importance of reliable data, Maya decided to build ten more identical bridge models. Each new model was constructed with the same materials and careful attention to detail, following her original design exactly. She then conducted ten additional weight-bearing trials . For each trial, she slowly added weights to the bridge, just as before, until it reached its breaking point. She carefully recorded the exact weight each bridge could hold before it failed. This systematic approach would help…

Related teaching materials

Browse more